So in 1982 Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons collapsed as a ‘together’ group along with the fan clubs. But it wasn’t the end, and although his family loses were devastating, Frankie Valli said:-
”That was the toughest I’ve ever had to go through in my whole life. I was screwed up for a long time after that. My doctor thought it would be in my best interests to continue working. I’m glad I did. I don’t think I’d make a good recluse.”
He is from tough stock and his response reflects his years ‘locked into’ being a performer……work was perhaps his escape…..…maybe it always has been? BUT the attempts at a return to ‘former glories’ from 1982 and 83 would fail for over two decades.
With little or no news and the collapse of the fan clubs hardly any news surfaced for UK fans still ‘missing’ the sounds of the ‘Who Loves You’ album. Gerry Polci and Don Ciccone had left the group we were told. Valli could not offer them the money or the creative direction to stay. Any unreleased recordings, where not good enough to persuade a record company to release them and promote an album, particularly with the sad state of the record business. Crewe was gone into retirement; disillusioned by the way the record business had changed. He no longer knew all the ‘execs’ and the ‘suits’ who now held the key positions and they dictated the music to be made. Charles Calello was an in demand arranger/producer having hits with Juice Newton…. And Bob Gaudio had dropped out of the music scene at this time. So we were led to believe.
The UK fans had heard that a studio session booked for April 1982 had taken place with 8 tracks laid done for album release but without Frankie Valli’s vocal. His throat problems were a big problem. The Snapper Box Set research later in 2020 uncovered a tape session of a set of tracks from this time in the LA storage. The statement by Frankie Valli that “8 tracks are being recorded for a new album” as reported at concert by Bruno Gargano was simply not true. The Snapper Music Box Set research uncovered a rehearsal session tape box and only one incomplete song…'You're Never Too Old To Rock and Roll' featured Frankie Valli’s voice. It was a song allegedly written by Frankie and Jerry Corbetta and began to appear in a very few concerts as a prelude to announcements of the new planned album. Bruno recorded the LIVE performance on 16th August 1982. Amazingly the LIVE recording made by Bruno has been salvaged and appears in the Snapper Music Box Set. It can be heard here
But unknown at the time and only discovered in the Snapper Box Set research was that 3 tracks were recorded at a following session in September of 1982 and completed and have lain there for 44 years. Only one track ‘Gypsy Woman’ would get released in 1988 on a compilation [‘Hits Digitally Enhanced’ by The Four Seasons Featuring Frankie Valli (Audio CD - February 1, 1991)- (also issued with extra Paper Box over-titled "the greatest hits" - February 1, 1991) EC– Curb D2-77304 ]
The other two were salvaged for the Snapper Music Box Set in 2023…...with ‘Testin’ The Water’ included but then ‘Deep In Your Love’ [ the earlier mentioned ‘Stoneground’ song from 1979] was lost in the Snapper ‘admin operation’ and remains unreleased but all can be heard here from the Master Tape below. It took till 2023 for us to hear what we might have loved in 1983!!!!
The tracks on this tape can be heard by clicking here or on the above image
The groups line-up was about to change yet again with the arrival of Chuck Wilson who would remain a Four Season until the 90s., Polci, Ciccone and Corbetta would leave the group and news started to dry up and the prospects for the future faded. The pressure wasn't helped as the record industry continued to spiral into recession and Warner Bros laid off 1000 people.
The cancellation of a planned 1982 tour had lost many UK fans. Years of lack of communication from the Four Seasons Partnership and broken promises re the group and record releases finally took its toll. As was shown in the last chapter many were totally disenchanted. It seemed that everything built from 1973 had collapsed.
Back in the USA, Frankie Valli kept up his intense touring programme and the group line-up for shows had changed again with Chuck Wilson on drums replacing Gerry Polci; Rex Robinson on bass replacing Don Ciccone and the returning Jerry Corbetta and Larry Lingle. A 20th Anniversary video was made of a LIVE Concert that was recorded live in 1982 at the Park West club in Chicago, Illinois. The video performance was originally released on home video (VHS/Beta) but not until May 1989 and later issued on DVD.
So with none of this known in 1982 and so little news from the USA, UK fans felt that the last link with the group that had given the Four Seasons their biggest hit ever, had somehow been broken. The whole identity of Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons appeared to be collapsing despite the efforts and investment in the 'Re-United' Tour. How would the remnants of the fan clubs react.? Without communication it seemed the band didn't exist any more.
The fans might have continued to support the group if communications and management had been better….and if the group had stayed stable and found a style and quality like they had achieved in 1975, 76 and 77. Fans had forgiven the sacking of the band in 1977 and followed and supported the attempt to re-establish the Four Seasons name with Frankie Valli as its leader. It was now evident that the music/record business with its inherent corruption had changed as had society with recession and austerity. Whilst the merging Corporations were reeling as sales dived, they saw FRANKIE VALLI & THE FOUR SEASONS now as simply an 'oldies group' that had no modern style, unlike the British 'new wave' groups that the wider public could relate too. The continued support from the small group of dedicated fans didn't seem to mean anything to the Partnership.
For many UK fans in 1971 it all started at Batley Variety Club
For UK fans it seemed like ‘closure’……..
”In a relationship, closure is a sense of peace, finality, and acceptance when a bond ends. It means you make sense of the breakup, let go of unanswered questions, and move forward without needing an apology or explanation from the other person”.
Back in the USA, by 1983 Frankie Valli had stabilised the group as ‘Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons’ keeping Chuck Wilson and Robbie Robinson and Larry Lingle, and once again he picked out good session musicians, offering them a career on the road that would continue to give him an outlet for his Four Seasons and solo hits. A very entertaining show was constructed that continued to lift fans and keep interest in the group as an ‘oldies band’ .
But the creative spark was gone and attempts at creating a ‘Four Seasons sound’, that appealed to the wider public was unsuccessful. Even an attempt to team up with the Beach Boys for an album failed and only the uninspiring ‘East Meets West’ came out as a single in September 1984 with no success.
The rest of the decade produced only two notable releases but they didn’t seem to focus on the past fans. Bob Gaudio moved into ‘digital recording’ in a big way. His attempt to ‘catch’ a ‘sound for the times’ happened in 1985 when from the wreckage of the above mentioned sessions which we knew nothing of in the UK – there emerged a record deal with …more sessions… and an album of ‘Club’ style up-tempo songs and a few ballads on the ill-fated 1985 album ‘Streetfighter’ by Frankie Valli And The Four Seasons . It was produced by Bob Crewe, Sandy Linzer, and Bob Gaudio. Lead vocals were performed by Frankie Valli, backed by a large crew of session musicians and vocalists[ including a still active Gerry Polci]. A US release that took a year to appear in the UK it was supposed to be supported by a UK tour but threats of a ‘terrorist’ attack on London at the time forced a cancellation. The album although digitally recorded and mixed, was the last ‘vinyl only’ release by the group as original material.
And the decade closed and with a ‘cobbled together’ set of tracks in response to the success of ‘Big Girls Don’t Cry’ in the Movie ‘Dirty Dancing’ it came as a CD release as the last of the Four Seasons ‘semi-original’ efforts in the 1980s, featuring only one unreleased song. ‘Gypsy Woman’ as a left over from the 1982 session mentioned above. Stefan Wriedt [our now deceased specialist sound engineer] said of this 1988 release in our CD Discography that it was...
”A CD produced by Turner D. Sentri [Bob Gaudio as the by-line he used on an instrumental release back in 1961] and re-mixed by Anthony D’Amico. ‘Enhanced’ here seems to mean ‘digital stereo’ re-masters of the several hits including ‘Big Girls Don’t Cry’ from the film ‘Dirty Dancing’ and the Dirty Dancing rap version. Special mixes of ‘Gypsy Woman’ (previously unreleased version of the Impressions song), ‘Book Of Love’ re-mixed by Tony D’Amico and ‘December 63’ and ‘Who Loves You’ produced by Bob Gaudio and re-mixed by Ben Liebrand. “
Whilst Bob Gaudio was focused on the ‘Dance’ Club Market the ‘majors’ were cashing in on the new CD ‘era’. By now all of the original Vee-Jay and Philips albums were appearing on CD Twofers[2 albums per CD] and Bill Inglot was recovering and re-mastering the original tapes from the 1960s v ault storage. He would actually have to re-construct the ‘Sherry and 11 Others’ 1962 album from various ‘copy’ tapes as the album ‘Master Tape’ was so deteriorated.
1988 started a flood of re-issues of albums on CD and fans were able to replace their worn vinyl with superior sounding masters[in most cases with ACE Records often being better than the original counterpart issues from Rhino in the USA]. Fans did feel happier than in a long time and the issue of Frankie Valli & The 4 Seasons - 25th Anniversary Collection by The Four Seasons as a 3 disc Audio CDs Box Set– [May or June 1988 {an alternative to the 4 LP vinyl issue from September 1987} and again in October 25, 1990 on Rhino] was a milestone in terms of including some of the unique versions from Bob Crewe’s 1968 vaults research project. This was the most important ‘product’ for fans since 1981 with sound ratings of the highest level ever and an “Essential Collectors’ edition of original Masters.
Enrolment in the Rock ‘n’ Roll Hall Of Fame in 1989 was a significant milestone for the original members of the group (as ‘Jersey Boys’ tells us) and by this time fans perhaps forgave and forgot the past and just wanted to see and hear the songs…’LIVE’.
But then nothing new would appear until 1992 and the ‘strange’ and last ever ‘original’ Four Seasons album and a ‘CD only’ release by them. Hope + Glory [later aka Hope & Glory] by Four Seasons (Audio CD - September 22, 1992 [9-92]) - Curb D2-77546. Released in September 1992 on the Curb label (catalog D2-77546). Hope + Glory is credited to the Four Seasons, with lead vocals by Frankie Valli. However it was never released in the UK and although the backstory is not known, clearly a ‘breakdown’ between the Partnership and the Label must have happened.
“The album was primarily produced and guided by Bob Gaudio, featuring contributions from veteran writers and producers like Bob Crewe and Sandy Linzer. The notable aspect for fans was the Album ‘Style’ .It was completely synthesized pop, new jack swing, and adult contemporary arrangements tailored to early '90s radio formats…..and one track even incorporated a ‘rap’ section by Chuck Wilson’.
..according to AI. No tracks were heard on radio and none have ever been performed by Frankie Valli and his line-ups of Four Seasons since. A Sandy Linzer – Steve Wise track ‘Even Now’ was rated by many fans at the time as worthy of single release and the originality was clear to all. BUT why no UK release and no promotion ?
With the 1990s however and even this further element of ‘neglect’ in terms of original material a UK tour in 1992 brought the fans back as so much time had passed since we were let down. There was however an acceptance of ‘oldies’ concerts amid a plethora of ‘digital club mixes’ on CD singles and re-issue albums even if to some of us it was a pretty pathetic way to cash in on the new era of CD based releases. We wanted new and promoted material.
The shows were well staged and produced and thoroughly entertaining, re-capturing the sound with the latest technology to create a vibrant ‘live’ experience. Frankie Valli had learned how to please his audience with his back catalogue and fans never stopped wanting to hear Frankie Valli sing LIVE. The Partnership realised the strength of the UK fan base and with another tour in 1994, once again everyone supported them. But in terms of recorded material only two ‘Dance’ mix albums came out in 1994 as the remix of ‘December 1963 (Oh, What a Night)hit #14 on Billboard(#11 in Cash Box). There had been multiple single ‘Dance Club’ versions in the USA/UK and Europe since 1988 and the ‘Digitally Enhanced’ versions and this would be the last 4 Seasons release of note until the ‘Beggin’ CLUB remix revival of 2007. All were focused on the new generations of fans.
For us longstanding UK fans life is too short to hold grudges but the ‘neglect’ has been ‘almost’ but not quite totally forgiven .
That is until the launch of ‘Jersey Boys’. Now they are bigger stars than ever. At the prompting of Bob Gaudio and Frankie Valli, Marshall Brickman and Rick Elise came up with the idea of immortalising a story of their ’original rise and fall’ with the best of their music and it worked incredibly. The show is brilliant and demonstrates that their achievements have been significant. But not being able to tell the story accurately, for entertainment reasons, means that they changed the story for the second half of the show to make it work theatrically…and no credit was given to the four guys who recorded the two songs that form the climax of the show ..’Who Loves You’ and ‘December 63’. In this story we have shown these songs would argue represent the climax of the groups ‘special’ sound.
With the emergence and success of Jersey Boys in 2004 – world wide,[and particularly with the London Cast – who UK fans loved] the identity of ‘Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons’ was re-established but based on the 1960s group……..and unfortunately the Partnerships again abandoned the UK as a touring venue until 2012.
So ends our story. The backstory of our research since 2011 is summarised in our ‘Research Coda’ and the salvage of the Typepad blog posts elsewhere on our web site
Amazingly a few, now much older, UK fans have held on to the friendships they had made back over the decades and continued to enjoy the past recordings, the concerts and the stories behind the music’s creation. This web site has remained and Newsletters continued to be produced up to Nr 68 in 2016.[see our main Menu]. Many fans today recognised the end of ‘Touring’ for Frankie Valli was becoming clear in recent tours to the UK. The Tour ‘stories’ by Lynn Boleyn will also appear in our blog Topic salvage in due course.
But updating this story to 2026 felt necessary to put everything in our shared life experiences as ‘performers and fans’ ……..in to perspective. The feedback from those fans and their interest and recollections have enabled this story to be put together. No 'official' information apart from the few communications quoted from, now deceased Attorney, Peter Bennett have been used in this story. The rest are quoted from published articles or from former Four Seasons personal recollections. Nothing from the Partnership has been sought in its compilation, as nothing would be forthcoming. It is purely a fans perspective. Back in 2009 when the story was first drafted it was a case of “the more things change…the more they remain the same.” The apathy of the Partnership had been clear to the true fans since 1997 with no ‘engagement’ even with the US and UK Newsletters and web sites. As ‘Jersey Boys’ created a new myth this story I felt was needed historically in some way to correct that, and hopefully it recognises the full story of ‘our Four Seasons’ which the stage musical sadly doesn’t do. That decision was another commercial choice by the FSP as those group members would have received ‘royalties’!!
Charles Alexander commented on our looking back at the 70s group and their collapse…..
“It's fine for people to investigate and discuss the past, if they like. But let's not blow the bad days out of proportion. Let's celebrate the totality of the Four Seasons' music and history. And let's celebrate the present”
We have done that of course by seeing, enjoying and promoting ‘Jersey Boys’, and supporting and attending the tour dates in the UK on every tour, but the fact is that ‘the present doesn’t properly respect the past’ and whilst ‘Jersey Boys’ is a production to entertain people and make them feel good (which it does very successfully), it is important to put the record straight. Bob and Frankie could have had the 70s Four Seasons announced as an intro to the shows ‘Who Loves You/December 63 finale’ or had info in the programme and book. That would have respected their creative contribution. The seven+ ‘Jersey Boys’ productions and film have made Bob and Frankie more money than they made in their entire careers with the group up to that date…… but for us who followed them back then simply recognising the contribution of others to the success is the level of respect anyone should expect.
Don Ciccone in Manchester in 1980 with promoter in the background
We’ve read that Bob and Frankie regard themselves as being the real core of the Four Seasons, and certainly their drive, leadership and talent carried the group’s success forward for so many years but it is like a ‘Premiership. or an Olympic winning team. The scorers and the captain may get the credit but none of it could have been achieved without the ‘team’. That core creative team was originally Crewe-Gaudio-Valli-Calello-Massi supplemented by Linzer and Randell. Subsequently it was Joe Long, Gerry Polci, Lee Shapiro, Don Ciccone and John Paiva.(and others in between who joined the line-up briefly)
And it is funny to look back when today Frankie Valli has shown he…. ‘just keeps going and going like that bunny on TV with the batteries’…..until he has reached 92. In an interview in the Village Voice on 8th September 1975….”I can’t see myself singing ‘Sherry’ at the age of 60” as he explained why he wants to move away from his ‘falsetto’ lead. So somehow he kept getting out on stage and performing with the help of Robbie Robinson, today’s technology and a group of singers who can amplify and enhance the harmonies just like in ‘Jersey Boys’. Technology overcame any ‘old-age’ affects on Frankie Valli’s voice for 2 decades up to 2026.
Throughout the 1970s he tried with the help of Bob Gaudio and Bob Crewe to move away from his falsetto………but now he knows he never was able to. But to his credit Frankie Valli has continued to entertain audiences to this year and that makes him a true ‘legend’.
‘Jersey Boys’ is perhaps the fitting tribute to the original group. Frankie Valli said in a recent interview...….
”We decided early on that if we were gonna do this, tell the story of Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons, we were gonna have to tell the truth - the whole truth - or it isn’t our story.”,
Well that hasn’t happened in the show as these chapters show . So as we enjoy the fiction of ‘Jersey Boys’, I feel happy that these Rise and Fall Of The NEW Four Seasons Chapters tell a more accurate story of that shows 2nd half...’for the record’.
And, what about the relationship with the fans?
Frankie Valli has tried to explain why the past lack of communication came about.
"In the early years we were scared to death someone would find out (about our connections) and record companies would drop us and radio stations wouldn't play us,” Valli says. “Someone would find out all the things that occurred in our lives. I mean guys went to jail, and there were robberies, gambling, all this stuff.".
It hasn’t been a story of ‘Harmony, Perfect Harmony’
But after writing this story, it is still hard to see why communications between management and fans was so ‘fractured’, for so long. It didn’t need to be if quality PR management had been maintained. I felt the words of a famous ‘Four Season’ sum up how he succeeded in music and it echoes through the conversations I have had with those involved in this story and which has informed this book.
“Music is one of the hallmarks of humanity”. Some make it for the sheer pleasure like Charlie Calello…”
my passion for music far exceeded any of the goals I was able to attain. Just the thrill of being a part of it was more than enough thanks.”
And although Frankie says...."It's about the group". ......"I mean, it has always been about the group."…that statement has to be questioned. When you reflect on the history of groups like The Temptations and The 4Tops, perhaps that statement would be true: but surely not with the Four Seasons? : maybe in the early days, before Nicky left.
Each Season since 1966 when Joe Long joined was just another ‘employee’. Although John Paiva thought of the group as a ‘family’, that was clearly not Bob and Frankie’s perception. It has never been about the group or the fans. For Frankie and Bob music is and remains primarily a money making business from my research and perspective.
This story may have also inferred that really the Four Seasons sound was lost because of Frankie Valli’s ambitions as a solo artist. That is open to debate and readers can make their own mind up. And maybe Bob and Frankie will maintain they acted reasonably and gave unknown musicians a chance to be stars? After all as Lee Shapiro bluntly says of those times:-
“As I have remarked to you before, the 70s "4 Seasons" were an outlet for Bob Gaudio's writing and production talents and we were all too happy to be a part of it. (And don't let nobody tell ya different!)”.
That may have been so……... but what type of ‘loyalty’ should have been expected, to both artists [group members] and fans.? However you judge it Bob and Frankie don’t come out of it smelling of roses. But if your aim is to make loads of money and do it your way, well they pass that measure of success with flying colours. If ‘respect’ is the measure well certainly from UK fans they have a huge amount due to them for their creativity and entertainment over the years.
But today, whatever the arguments, it is the creation of the music that fans are really focused on. Understanding how it was made enhances its enjoyment and this has been our focus. But we also sadly have had to accept the loss of our dear friend, Don Ciccone who passed away on October 8, 2016, at the age of 70 in Ketchum, Idaho and Joe Long from Covid on April 21, 2021, at the age of 88. And as a fan base we owe so much to departed fans Rex Woodard, Stefan Wriedt, Frank Rovello and John Hornsby. All helped me write this story.
In compiling this story my aim has been to show that Bob Gaudio’s original idea to take the group sound away from a falsetto led approach would eventually succeed spectacularly. From 1966 onwards we have shown in these chapters how Bob Gaudio expressed his creative talents through the ‘brand’ name…’The Four Seasons’.[so this ‘Society’ (of fans and collectors) is named after them.] Bob Gaudio has said he “didn’t try to write hits’…but Bob Crewe did that. Gaudio just wrote from his perspective, which is how I have interpreted his interviews. There were good and bad times. When they were good they were very good.
This book doesn’t always make pleasant reading but it is what it is and it does celebrate the music that we bought and the guys we supported. I don’t believe I have blown the bad times out of proportion. I would hope that Frankie and Bob won’t mind that me and the fans ‘sing the praise of the former members’ contribution’ or of recalling how we, the fans and members of the group felt.? Somebody should recognise that contribution! No longer naïve, we now see through the past commercial hype, whilst still loving the music.
The most successful Four Seasons ever were in 1976 and 1977 : a brilliantly talented group, and they all contributed to the sound created and the significant chart success….in spite of , perhaps, a less than favourable employment arrangement for group members. Now speaking on behalf of the body of fans, we have a description in print of what they did and how it eventually fell apart for us all. We were lucky to get what we got and we can continue to celebrate what they achieved and hopefully we have to some extent set the record straight for everyone…the group…the Partnership but most of all for the fans.
And we have been able to show that the Four Seasons and others all played their part in creating the sounds we love
Only serious fans, good musicians and critics think popular music should have integrity and credibility. This story shows the music business warts and all. We the fans have always been too idealistic as fans quotes from 1982 and perhaps my own here show.
But members of the Four Seasons have demonstrated great affection and appreciation of the fans and a love for their music. One Four Season……the man who paved the way most in my opinion to enabling Bob Crewe, Bob Gaudio, Frankie Valli and the creative talents of the group to achieve the peaks they achieved, best sums up what we the ‘serious fans’ most respect…..Charlie Calello in interview with Stuart Miller says it for us all…..”
In a person’s life time, one of the things that I’ve observed is that when you look back to any period in history, people do not remember who the richest guy was, they don’t remember who the most successful person was, who was the prettiest, this, that and the other thing. There are basically very few things that people remember as they look back in history. They remember art, they remember literature and they remember music. And I know that a 100 years from today, people will be looking back at the 60s and 70s saying, "Hey, look at this. The 4 Seasons". And that’s the thrill ……….of having been involved in it. “
Manchester Apollo 1977
That great art he helped create, and is why we still follow the music and respect the creative talent and the warmth of former Four Seasons who have contributed to this back-story.
And with our thirst for knowledge through the web site and blog our interest led to a ‘breakthrough’ in 2018 and the commitment to a project to create the best ‘Anthology’ ever of ‘Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons’ recorded work. That research story is told in our ‘Research-Coda’ that follows this Chapter. It plots the timeline of the remains of a fan club that became a web based UK ‘Appreciation Society’ of the Four Seasons after the collapse of the ‘formal’ fan clubs , and shows perhaps how with the help of AI we have ‘morphed’ into a curated ‘Archive’ Management Team:-
THE FOUR SEASONS HISTORICAL SOCIETY.
References: Goldmine Article – The Four Seasons - A Lesson in Survival by Rex Woodard 1981: “Out Of Season” by John Paiva (unpublished biography); Four Seasons UK Appreciation Society Newsletters: USA Newsletters by Steve Bailey and Bill Witkowski: Special thanks for contribution to: John Hornsby: Charles Calello: Lee Shapiro: Stefan Wriedt: Frank Rovello: Ken Charmer: George Ingram: Lynn Boleyn: Malcolm Grace: Photos courtesy of John Paiva and Brian Lomas; Pic sleeves courtesy of Ray Nichol: